Why the FIRE Movement Will Never Die

The worldview of financial independence and early retirement has been under assault recently. Suze Orman proclaimed to the world her hate for the FIRE movement on the Afford Anything podcast and set off a firestorm that culminated in a Washington Post article and a belated apology in the form of back-stepping her comments; seems she misunderstood the FIRE movement before passing judgement. (Or, perhaps, books sales were involved. Just throwing that out there.)

One of our very own, Sam Dogen of the Financial Samurai blog, has also turned a critical eye to the nascent FIRE movement. In a MarketWatch article Dogen is reported as saying FIRE stands for:

Foolish Idealist Returns to Employer

rather than Financial Independence/Retire Early.

Ouch!

The promise of financial security and early retirement will never grow old. The FIRE community has delivered since the invention of money and is still going strong. Learn the ancient lessons for a better today.

The promise of financial security and early retirement will never grow old. The FIRE community has delivered since the invention of money and is still going strong. Learn the ancient lessons for a better today.

What precipitated the rebuke was a simple one-month market decline. December 2018 was the worst stock market performance by most broad indexes since 1931. And the death of the movement was declared and a new acronym was created with the hope of replacing the Old World Order. What has so far been the shallowest of bear markets (defined as a 20% or greater decline from a recent market top) has heralded the end of times once again. And we barely (pun intended) entered bear market territory!

It is true the market could once again turn lower and inflict pain on the foolish. It is also true I’ve been critical of the FIRE community myself a time or three. And don’t think for a minute I didn’t catch hell for it too, only on a smaller scale. (Guys, you know when you link an article on Reddit, the web host—that would be me—can see it. I heard the nasty things said about my pedigree.)

As critical of the the FIRE community and the movement as Orman, Dogen and a certain wealthy accountant who shall remain unnamed are, the movement is never going to die! That’s right. The FIRE movement has grown large enough it can make the economic needle wobble now and again and that makes some people nervous. But the movement, the community, will never die.

Who Started the FIRE Movement?

Modern acolytes can be forgiven for thinking Get Rich Slowly, Early Retirement Extreme or even Mr. Money Mustache kicked this whole thing into gear. The truth is the concept of the FIRE movement has been around for a very, very long time.

Retirement, or at least the ability to to live a hedonistic lifestyle, appeals to many people. Age has nothing to do with it. Punching a clock working for the man gets old real fast when you don’t have perspective. Until you realize how useless life becomes when you spend each day creating no value and have no real reason to live do you begin to understand. Then the job looks more appealing. Or starting a business. In either case you get real interaction with people on a similar mission and it brings the spice back to life. (Redditors, fire up your engines!)

Join a community where financial freedom is the phrase of the day. Early retirement and other financial goals are possible when you become part of the FIRE community.

Join a community where financial freedom is the phrase of the day. Early retirement and other financial goals are possible when you become part of the FIRE community.

But I contend, as I often have in this blog, that retirement had nothing to do with the FIRE movement. It was never about retirement; that was the dream sold to get victims in the door. FIRE has always been about wealth, about independence and freedom. People never wanted to be retired like and old worn out machine. They wanted meaningful activities. Financial independence allows the freedom to choose and that is what people really wanted all along.

And still they keep searching because they don’t understand what it is they really desire.

The beauty of the FIRE lifestyle is it encourages elimination of debt and all the stress it brings and investing intelligently in index funds with a long-term time horizon. Without debt you can withstand a lot of economic instability. Every minor wobble in economic activity has the debtor soiling his, ah, well . . .  We’ll leave it at that.

People hate living paycheck to paycheck and love the idea they can choose their destiny. FIRE delivers on that promise. And the concept is not a modern one.

Benjamin Franklin spoke often of money and wealth. In a way he was the father of the American FIRE movement. But if you go back 2,000 years you can read the parables of Jesus and see that over half his recorded teachings involve money and wealth. But even that isn’t the beginning! Proverbs in the Old Testament teaches plenty of lesson about money. I don’t want to go all religion on you, but I do want to point out that the teachings of the FIRE community are not new.

In fact, if you want to know who actually started the FIRE movement you have to go all the way back to Grog, the caveman, as he taught around the evening campfire. He would say to the young and old, “No debt!” Grunt. “Debt bad. Invest in community coconut index fund.”

As funny as I might think I am, man discovered these principles early on. Shakespeare peppered his verse with financial wisdom. Every religion I studied speaks about wealth, debt and money. Great leaders in business from the beginning of time had to acquire the skills of the modern FIRE community if they wanted to survive.

The truth is the FIRE movement discovered some of the oldest lessons of the species and dressed it up in contemporary clothing. Nothing wrong with that. Except some, the snake oil salesmen, don’t get it because they are peddling large loads of manure and they need to discredit the wise to move today’s load of. . .

Evolution

The FIRE movement is not dead; it is evolving. A long bull market in stocks has lured many new converts. Secretly they kept their debt while plowing at least a bit more into index funds. As long as the elevator raced higher on the back of a SpaceX rocket things would be good. Besides, you saw how Elon Musk developed rockets that gently land themselves, ready for instant reuse.

A short market decline will not end the FIRE movement. The Great Depression didn’t kill the philosophy of the FIRE movement, though it had different names back then. The worse the economy the stronger the FIRE message appeals! Mild economic downturns and market corrections will not slow this animal down. If the economy and/or stock market get vulgar the FIRE community message will evolve as it should.

“It was the worst of times, it was the best of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness. . . ” wrote Dickens to begin A Tale of Two Cities. Things haven’t changed much in 160 years. It doesn’t end any better either. (You can read the book to understand what I mean.) Things are good right now. Jobs are plentiful, prices relatively low and many investments have moved significantly higher over the past decade. But government, corporate and personal debt are all at record highs, some precipitously so. The best and worst of times. Especially when you realize the debt will be a harsh slave in the next economic cleansing, same as the last.

The best is ahead of us! The longest bull market in the U.S. lasted a decade, starting in the early 1990s until the current bull market. To put this in perspective, the two longest bull runs in the market happened in the past 30 years. The vast majority have no idea what it was like prior to 1980. For the old guys who do, we take extra caution to keep debt low, if we use the acid at all, placing our wealth in a broad mix of businesses throwing off a steady stream of income. We know there are no guarantees, but we structure our financial lives to withstand a very strong storm.

FIRE of the past was about frugality (it always was about frugality) and retiring from enforced labor due to financial condition. This is changing to something more valuable for the acolyte and society at large. Retirement is becoming less the goal and creating value the new mantra.

It’s not about work to fill the day; it is about fulfilling work. It’s about creating something of value, something we can be proud of. Curing a disease, building an advanced rocket or electric car is part of the New World Order inside the FIRE community.

We discovered it was easy in the modern world to save money and invest it. We discovered how easy it was to build a massive net worth, negating the necessity of work. But we also discovered it left us empty.

FIRE’d Up

The modern incarnation of the FIRE movement is young, made up of millennials who thought the dream of retiring at 30 would make their lives meaningful. They now have the experience to know that was a lie.

Travel has been a massive draw for many entering the FIRE lifestyle. What was discovered is extended vacations or a gap year are perfect for exploratory travel. Then, when the road turns weary, there is a home where people gather most days of the week to create an even better world. Call it work; call it your business. Call it what you want.

Financial freedom and retirement are not hollow goals. Join the FIRE community and feel the Strength of a community versed in helping people achieve their financial goals.

Financial freedom and retirement are not hollow goals. Join the FIRE community and feel the Strength of a community versed in helping people achieve their financial goals.

Social media is filled with people in desperate need of financial help. Maybe it’s a tax issue, or debt or other unique challenge. A few weeks ago I saw in a private Facebook group a young lady who was worried about the market. She put the down payment to a home they wished to purchase in an index fund last June and the fund was now down 25%, or $20,000 for her. She wanted advice. Many offered. I said: If you put a home down payment in the market what you are saying is you will buy your home five or more years in the future. Any sooner and you should not have put the money in the market. It was shallow comfort, I’m sure. But if I’m lucky I helped two or three people thinking of making the same mistake.

Orman was wrong. So are most people inside the movement!

The FIRE movement is nothing to hate and the people inside the community should grow some thicker skin. It is said: Of which much is given, much is expected. Those in the community have built a larger fortune than most. Jealousy is a given, especially from those unwilling to take the simple steps outlined for thousands of years by one FIRE community after another.

People will hate you for being rich and hate you for being poor. I’d rather be hated for being rich; it’s less painful.

The modern FIRE community has a gift unlike previous FIRE movements. We are not limited to the few wise locals living the FIRE (or whatever name it was called in the past) lifestyle. We are a worldwide movement, community. The internet has made us legion. We have a massive support group and an awesome responsibility to our world, our community, our family, ourselves.

We have a gift we must share! A market decline, even a large one, will not unravel the FIRE movement. I disagree with Dogen and the MarketWatch article. We don’t need another acronym to identify with responsible financial activities.

The basics make us great. Michael Jordan wasn’t great because he could make the three-point shot (though he was darn good at it, too); he was great because he mastered the basics, like the layup.

Money basics are not that hard and work extremely well. Teach your children, family and friends. Teach your community and share with the world. Together we can make a difference; together we can change the world.

The FIRE community will have its challenges and may soon go under a different name. For those in the know, we know exactly what the message is. It is as old as Grog and his nightly chat around the FIRE.

Remember to share the same message with your children around the hearth.

It is our future. Our only hope.

 

More Wealth Building Resources

Credit Cards can be a powerful money management tool when used correctly. Use this link to find a listing of the best credit card offers. You can expand your search to maximize cash and travel rewards.

Personal Capital is an incredible tool to manage all your investments in one place. You can watch your net worth grow as you reach toward financial independence and beyond. Did I mention Personal Capital is free?

Side Hustle Selling tradelines yields a high return compared to time invested, as much as $1,000 per hour. The tradeline company I use is Tradeline Supply Company. Let Darren know you are from The Wealthy Accountant. Call 888-844-8910, email Darren@TradelineSupply.com or read my review.

Medi-Share is a low cost way to manage health care costs. As health insurance premiums continue to sky rocket, there is an alternative preserving the wealth of families all over America. Here is my review of Medi-Share and additional resources to bring health care under control in your household.

QuickBooks is a daily part of life in my office. Managing a business requires accurate books without wasting time. QuickBooks is an excellent tool for managing your business, rental properties, side hustle and personal finances.

cost segregation study can reduce taxes $100,000 for income property owners. Here is my review of how cost segregations studies work and how to get one yourself.

Amazon is a good way to control costs by comparison shopping. The cost of a product includes travel to the store. When you start a shopping trip to Amazon here it also supports this blog. Thank you very much!

 

Keith Taxguy

13 Comments

  1. Planedoc on January 21, 2019 at 7:14 am

    Exactly.

    Work can be good.

  2. FullTimeFinance on January 21, 2019 at 9:46 am

    I’ve never been a big retire early person unless it’s defined as 55. I also agree with the concept that retirement won’t give your life purpose….

    But I choose to be a part of the community for a very important reason, FI. Financial independence and education are the keys to success regardless of packaging. What you do with them is personal. If the worst impact of the organization is millions wake up and start saving for a rainy day then the world is a better place.

    • Keith Taxguy on January 21, 2019 at 9:52 am

      You echo my feelings exactly, FTF. The RE never thrilled me, but the FI has always done so. There is a lot of value in the community mass media forgets.

  3. Matt on January 21, 2019 at 12:10 pm

    I used to have the fantasy of retiring early, moving to the beach and spending the day watching the waves. Then I realized I would be bored in 5 minutes and would probably waste away. As I get older I start thinking about what will I do when the time comes to hang it up. Traveling sounds ok but honestly not that thrilling. I think a person’s goal should be to find the job or opportunity that gives them purpose. The rest will work itself out. And avoid debt of course.

    Great blog . Any book recommendations for studying other religions?

    • Keith Taxguy on January 22, 2019 at 11:29 am

      Matt, the best books on religion I’ve read to date are Eliade’s History of Religious Ideas Vol 1, 2 & 3 and Jordan Peterson’s Maps of Meaning.

      There are several others to consider as well. Joseph Campbell is good to read, for example. I have a couple hundred books on the subject. I’d have to go through the stack to see what other gems I’m forgetting. Let me know if you want a longer reading list.

  4. Mr. Hobo Millionaire on January 21, 2019 at 6:08 pm

    Instead of FIRE, I came up with WOOT! – Work On (Your) Own Terms. I like that term better.

    Another solid article, Keith. I shake my head at the folks who have negative comments about this “movement” — however old it is. Anyone focused on FIRE, whatever happens in the future, will be much better than anyone not focused on FIRE. There is no downside to “attempting” FIRE. Even for the folks who attempt Lean FIRE, I’m sure if their assets went from 500K to 200K, they would immediately come up with a plan to go back to work (and really they would much sooner). But even at 200K and looking for a job, they’re still 200 times better than folks who don’t even have $1000 in assets (which we’ve all heard those stats).

    • Keith Taxguy on January 21, 2019 at 7:06 pm

      And if you have 400k in debt and lose your job you still have 400k in debt. If you engage any form of FIRE you are better off than the spendthrift. Yes, your account value can decline temporarily. But you still have an account value throwing off an income stream (dividend yield). The yield is far more stable than market gyrations.

    • Kristen on January 22, 2019 at 9:33 am

      I’m a WOOTer and I didn’t know it until now! Love the term, and my husband and I are definitely in that camp. Knock out debt, build wealth, and, especially after reaching some pre-determined FU-money number, it’s all gravy.

  5. Amanda on January 22, 2019 at 5:36 pm

    ” Sam Dogen of the Financial Samurai blog … saying FIRE stands for: Foolish Idealist Returns to Employer”

    From the Financial Samurai Blog:
    “Author Bio: Sam… spent 13 years working… and retired at age 34 in San Francisco.

    It’s kind of odd that a guy who did exactly what the FIRE movement is about is so critical of it.

    • Keith Taxguy on January 22, 2019 at 6:11 pm

      Amanda, I think it’s okay to be critical. I happen to handle the taxes for Mr. Money Mustache and I am critical of the RE part of FIRE. What strikes me most is the condescending nature of the acronym as a form of nihilism. One month of market decline/modest bear market (so far) has us predicting the end of financial responsibility (what FIRE is really about). I just don’t see that or agree with it.

      The best part of FIRE is the evolving nature of financial advice encouraging sound investing, spending and budgeting behavior. The message will continue into the future as it occupied the past because it is so powerful and beneficial.

      For the record, I never met Sam Dogen. From what I’ve read and heard he is a hell of a nice guy. And the article was published by MarketWatch so the reporting could be slanted or taken out of context.

    • Amit M on February 9, 2019 at 10:22 am

      Unfortunately Sam Dogen of Financial Samurai blog is NOT a decent person. He is deceitful and dishonest. He promotes financial products on his web site glibly, in an attempt to profit from sponsorships. Worse, he misrepresents his knowledge and greatly exaggerates his net worth. See this for more about him:

      https://www.amitmay.com/financial-samurai-sam-dogen-fraud-liar.html

  6. Katie Camel on January 22, 2019 at 7:26 pm

    I agree that some form of FIRE has pretty much always existed – we’re not unique – but I can’t imagine having retired at 30 and doing nothing, even traveling indefinitely. For me, FI is primarily about freedom — freedom to choose how I spend my time, whether it’s still working at my job, though with reduced hours, or leaving to pursue other meaningful work (my current job is meaningful, albeit more stressful than I want some days). As much as I LOVE traveling and have seen a good chunk of the world, I don’t want to retire to just travel. It’d be part of what I do, much like it already is, but I’m very much a homebody. I derive as much joy from being a home with my dog or family and cooking great meals. I actually get homesick nearly every time I travel because I begin to miss my dog and kitchen. That homesickness doesn’t last long, but it nearly always happens while traveling. Anyway, I love writing and have been writing since I was a kid. If I do manage to FIRE at a relatively early age, which I’m on target to do, then I’ll likely have another career as a full-time writer and sometime traveler. Being a stay-at-home-dog-mom wouldn’t be so bad either. 😉 Either way, I think most of us FIRE folk just want to find another way in which to be productive and serve society, but having the financial ability to walk away from work we no longer care to do.

  7. Sam on February 5, 2019 at 6:02 pm

    I’ve learned a great deal following bloggers and podcasters who share on financial literacy and/ or financial freedom. The community provides insight from varying perspectives for life optimization which has been very practical and helpful – increase income and save as much as you are able, 401k contributions, Roth IRA investments, VTSAX index funds. Good read and glad to have discovered the community no longer than 2 years ago.

Leave a Comment





%d bloggers like this: